Who controls the baseline?
A comparison is only as useful as the reference retained outside the changed files.
Research note · November 14, 2026Research question
What happens if both the model folder and its baseline can be replaced together?
Method
- Create a baseline for a controlled folder and retain a copy in a separately controlled location. Record who can replace each copy and how reviewers identify the intended reference.
- Change the folder and regenerate its adjacent baseline. Compare the folder once against the new local baseline and once against the retained original. Both outcomes should remain visible with their reference identities.
- If a signed reference is used, verify signer identity and authorization separately from the artifact digest. Treat an unexpected signer or reference revision as a review event rather than automatically accepting it.
Records to retain
- Baseline digest and storage location
- Reference revision history
- Access and replacement policy
- Signer identity where applicable
Source basis
Content hashing checks agreement with a reference. TUF’s separation of trusted metadata roles and Sigstore’s identity-based verification illustrate why obtaining an expected digest is a trust decision of its own.
Interpretation & limits
Keeping a local copy is not tamper resistance. The proposed test demonstrates reference replacement, not protection against a fully compromised host. No custody mechanism is claimed as deployed.
Next experiments
- Test accidental baseline replacement during an update.
- Define a recovery procedure for a lost or compromised reference.
References
Technical reference
Implementation details supporting this note, drawn directly from the maintained documentation. These are technical references, not additional papers or new experimental results. Expand a topic to inspect its method, fields and limits.