Skip to research
Vraelis Research
All researchResearch methods / Reference note and proposed protocol

Define the evaluation population

A result needs a stated population before its score can be interpreted.

Research note · November 14, 2026

Research question

Which systems and conditions does an evaluation actually represent?

Method

  1. Define the unit of evaluation, such as a file, release, device, session or scenario. List inclusion and exclusion rules before selecting cases.
  2. Record how the sample was obtained and which conditions are absent. Keep convenient examples distinct from a representative sample of a deployment population.
  3. Report results by relevant strata as well as in aggregate. A large number of near-identical cases should not hide the absence of an important environment or failure mode.

Records to retain

  • Sampling unit and eligibility rules
  • Selection procedure
  • Population and sample differences
  • Case-level outcomes

Source basis

NIST’s AI RMF emphasizes context and intended use in risk management. Scikit-learn’s cross-validation guidance similarly shows that evaluation structure must reflect dependencies in the data. Neither makes a convenience sample representative by itself.

Interpretation & limits

This protocol does not supply a dataset or an estimate of real-world failure frequency. Claims should remain bounded by the cases and conditions actually evaluated.

Next experiments

  • Write the population definition before collecting more fixtures.
  • Identify one missing stratum that could change the conclusion.

References

  1. NIST AI Risk Management Framework
  2. Scikit-learn cross-validation

Technical reference

Implementation details supporting this note, drawn directly from the maintained documentation. These are technical references, not additional papers or new experimental results. Expand a topic to inspect its method, fields and limits.

Related notes